1940 :: New York Rangers
1941 :: Boston Bruins
1942 :: Toronto Maple Leafs
1943 :: Detroit Red Wings
1944 :: Montreal Canadiens
1945 :: Toronto Maple Leafs
1946 :: Montreal Canadiens
1947 :: Toronto Maple Leafs
1948 :: Toronto Maple Leafs
1949 :: Toronto Maple Leafs

1950 :: Detroit Red Wings
1951 :: Toronto Maple Leafs
1952 :: Detroit Red Wings
1953 :: Montreal Canadiens
1954 :: Detroit Red Wings
1955 :: Detroit Red Wings
1956 :: Montreal Canadiens
1957 :: Montreal Canadiens
1958 :: Montreal Canadiens
1959 :: Montreal Canadiens